Peer Review Process
Qawa’id: Journal of Arabic Language and Literature [E-ISSN: 3123-5484] implements an Open Peer Review model as part of its commitment to transparency, accountability, academic objectivity, and publication integrity. This review model is designed to ensure that every manuscript considered for publication meets appropriate academic standards, demonstrates a clear scholarly contribution, and undergoes a transparent and accountable evaluation process.
The peer-review process involves the editorial team and at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise in Arabic language, Arabic literature, linguistics, translation studies, Arabic language teaching and learning, or other related disciplines. All participants are expected to uphold professional standards, academic integrity, and publication ethics throughout the editorial and review processes.
Principles of Open Peer Review
The implementation of Open Peer Review at Qawa’id is guided by the following principles:
-
Reviewer Identity Transparency
Reviewer identities may be disclosed to authors as part of the journal's commitment to transparency and accountability in scholarly evaluation.
-
Transparency of Review Reports
Review reports and comments may be published alongside the final article, allowing readers to understand the evaluation process and revisions undertaken by the authors.
-
Constructive Academic Dialogue
Authors and reviewers may engage through the editorial system to provide clarification, exchange academic arguments, and improve manuscript quality under editorial supervision.
-
Reviewer Recognition
Reviewers may receive formal recognition for their scholarly contributions. Reviewer names may be disclosed in published review reports with their consent.
-
Objectivity and Independence
Reviewers must evaluate manuscripts based on scholarly quality, methodological rigor, originality, argumentation, and academic contribution, without discrimination based on the author's identity, institutional affiliation, background, or personal characteristics.
-
Publication Ethics and Academic Integrity
Editors, reviewers, and authors must uphold academic ethics, disclose potential conflicts of interest, respect scholarly procedures, and maintain integrity throughout the editorial process.
Characteristics of the Peer Review Process
To ensure transparency and academic quality, Qawa’id implements the following peer-review practices:
-
Reviewer identities may be disclosed to authors during the review process.
-
Reviewers evaluate manuscripts according to relevant academic and disciplinary standards.
-
Review reports may be made publicly available alongside published articles.
-
Authors are given opportunities to respond to reviewer comments and revise their manuscripts.
-
Reviewers may receive recognition for their contributions to the evaluation process.
-
All reviews must be conducted objectively, constructively, professionally, and without discrimination.
-
Editorial decisions are based on scholarly quality, reviewer recommendations, and the quality of manuscript revisions.
Stages of the Peer Review Process
To ensure that every manuscript is handled systematically, transparently, and consistently, Qawa’id applies the following editorial and peer-review stages:
1. Manuscript Submission and Technical Screening
Manuscripts submitted through the journal's online submission system are initially examined by the editorial team to verify document completeness, formatting, article structure, citation style, and compliance with the journal's author guidelines and publication ethics.
2. Originality and Similarity Screening
Before proceeding to substantive peer review, manuscripts undergo a similarity check using plagiarism detection software. This screening is conducted to identify potential plagiarism, inappropriate text duplication, and redundant publication.
The similarity report serves as an initial editorial assessment and does not automatically determine whether a manuscript is accepted or rejected. Editors evaluate the findings in their academic context.
3. Editorial Screening
The editor conducts an initial assessment of the manuscript's suitability for the journal's Focus and Scope, basic academic quality, originality, research objectives, relevance of the literature review, and methodological appropriateness.
Manuscripts that fall outside the journal's scope or fail to meet minimum academic standards may be rejected at this stage (desk rejection).
4. Editor Assignment
Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are assigned to an editor with relevant expertise in the subject area. The assigned editor coordinates the review process, editorial communication, manuscript revisions, and final editorial decision.
5. Reviewer Selection
The editor appoints at least two independent reviewers with expertise relevant to the manuscript's subject matter. Reviewer selection considers academic qualifications, publication experience, subject-area expertise, and potential conflicts of interest.
Reviewers must be independent of the authors and must disclose any circumstances that could compromise their impartiality.
6. Peer Review Evaluation
Reviewers conduct a comprehensive assessment of the manuscript based on the following criteria:
-
Originality and novelty of the research.
-
Relevance to the journal's focus and scope.
-
Clarity of the research problem and objectives.
-
Strength of the theoretical framework and literature review.
-
Appropriateness of the research methodology.
-
Quality and validity of the research data.
-
Accuracy of data analysis and interpretation.
-
Depth and relevance of the discussion.
-
Theoretical and practical contributions.
-
Quality and currency of references.
-
Clarity of conclusions and research implications.
-
Quality of Arabic language usage or the language of the manuscript.
-
Overall academic presentation and scholarly contribution.
Reviewers provide constructive comments, recommendations, and suggestions to help authors improve the academic quality of their manuscripts.
7. Author Revision
Authors are given the opportunity to revise their manuscripts based on reviewers' and editors' comments. Revisions must address the substantive issues raised during the evaluation process and be accompanied by a point-by-point response to reviewer comments when requested.
If necessary, revised manuscripts may be returned to the reviewers for further evaluation.
8. Editorial Decision
After considering the review reports and the quality of manuscript revisions, the editor makes the editorial decision. The possible decisions include:
-
Accept — The manuscript is accepted for publication and proceeds to the production stage.
-
Minor Revision — The manuscript requires minor corrections before acceptance.
-
Major Revision — The manuscript requires substantial revisions and may undergo further review.
-
Resubmit for Review — The manuscript requires fundamental improvements before it can be reconsidered for publication.
-
Reject — The manuscript does not meet the journal's academic standards or falls outside its focus and scope.
The final editorial decision rests with the editor and is based on the overall editorial assessment, reviewer reports, and the quality of revisions. It is not determined solely by an individual reviewer's recommendation.
9. Copyediting and Layout
Accepted manuscripts proceed to the copyediting stage to ensure linguistic accuracy, consistency of article structure, citation and reference formatting, tables, figures, and other supporting elements.
The manuscripts are subsequently prepared through layout editing and proofreading before publication.
10. In-Press and Publication
Manuscripts that have been formally accepted and have completed the required editorial procedures may first be made available in the In-Press section. Following completion of the publication process, articles are officially published in the regular issue of Qawa’id according to the journal's publication schedule.
Plagiarism and Originality Policy
Qawa’id: Journal of Arabic Language and Literature is committed to maintaining originality, academic integrity, and ethical standards throughout the scholarly publication process. All submitted manuscripts undergo a similarity check using Turnitin before or during the peer-review process.
The similarity screening aims to identify potential plagiarism, redundant publication, inappropriate self-plagiarism, and the use of sources without proper acknowledgment. The similarity report is considered by the editor as part of the manuscript evaluation process.
Authors bear full responsibility for the originality and authenticity of their manuscripts, including all research data, analyses, quotations, illustrations, and references. Plagiarism, data fabrication, data falsification, citation manipulation, and other forms of academic misconduct are strictly prohibited.
If potential academic misconduct is identified, the editorial team may request clarification from the authors and take appropriate action according to the nature and severity of the violation. Such actions may include requesting corrections, suspending the editorial process, rejecting the manuscript, or taking post-publication action if misconduct is discovered after publication.
Through this policy, Qawa’id seeks to ensure that every published article upholds the principles of originality, academic integrity, transparency, and scholarly accountability, while making a meaningful contribution to the advancement of Arabic language and literature studies.
